Society of Service
SOCIETY OF SERVICE
The long one

Held up by strangers

Almost everything you leaned on today was done for you by people you'll never meet. I think that's one of the most astonishing things about being alive, and we've built a world that barely notices. Come and have a look.

WEL COME NEW HERE? COME IN. THE KETTLE'S ALREADY ON.

If you're new here: welcome, honestly, come in! The kettle's on. (Someone else filled it, obviously.) For five years I've written Society of Service a piece at a time, about whatever had got hold of me that week: a SEND tribunal, a relay race, Dolly Parton, sun loungers, the BBC, a cow. It looked like a jumble, even to me. Then I noticed every one of them was about the same thing, seen from a different angle. This page puts the whole of it in one place.

You don't need to have read a word of the rest, and you certainly don't need to agree with me. You only need to have been looked after by a stranger at some point today, and you have, so you're in.

Who this is for

I'm writing this for you if you work in a service. Any service. If you're on the frontline of one, on the phone or at the counter or on the ward or at the school gate at twenty to nine. If you look after someone, paid or unpaid, and go to bed tired in a way nobody measures. If you've started to worry that we've forgotten how to care at any kind of scale. If you're a senior leader in a mega service, or a consultant trying to change one, and you're confused as to why your efforts to make things better aren't working. (I've been that consultant.) And if you've ever sat on hold for the best part of an hour, or across a desk from someone reading a script, and thought: we put a man on the moon, so why can't we treat this child with dignity and respect?

That last question is mine. I spent thirty minutes on the phone to the DWP with my daughter, who's sixteen and autistic. Around 90% of the call was their script. She was bewildered, and understandably so.

If any of that is you, pull up a chair. And if none of it is, you're still on the receiving end of all of it every day, so pull one up anyway.

Who it's by

Joel Bailey: twenty-five years of designing services, and plenty of mistakes
Joel Bailey

I've been designing services for about twenty-five years. I started in government, on businesslink.gov.uk, the website for small businesses, where I spent most of the 2000s turning tax guidance into plain English and building one of the UK government's first user-centred service design practices. Then nearly five years at Capita, then Director of the UK studio at Livework (the agency that pioneered service design), then EY Seren, working with the big banks. Along the way I've worked on the NHS, Army recruitment, teachers' pensions, TV licensing, council services and mobile phones. These days I help run an AI company, which is why section 08 is written by someone building the machines.

I should own up to something. A lot of what I write about here comes from my own mistakes. I've fallen into pretty much every trap I describe, and spent time climbing my way out. At Capita I was brought in to lead service design, which a lot of the time ended up being cutting "avoidable contact" and shifting people from a phone call to self-service. So when this page says the loop is broken, I'm not pointing at somebody else. I had a hand in it.

I've also been on the other side of the counter for a long time. My dad was a baker for twenty-five years, the most ancient of services. I've spent years in the SEND system on my daughter's behalf. I've done more therapy than I'd like to admit. I've meditated since I was sixteen, most recently for fifteen years in a local secular Buddhist community.

And I'm a nerd about it. Unapologetically. Around 2000 my dad asked what I wanted for Christmas and I asked for Brian Eno's Music for Airports and a hardback of Bowling Alone. He thought this was a very strange thing for a young man to want. (It confirmed a long-held family suspicion that an alien had been left in the house.) I'm an ex-librarian, too. On a work trip to Boston I bailed on the business dinner to ask a librarian for books about service. There were hardly any, which is partly why this page exists. (Those three hours with a librarian are a very fond memory. Total nerd.)

I don't have neat answers. What I've got is twenty-five years on both sides of the counter, some models that are works in progress, and an obsession with a world I think we've stopped looking at. That's my case for half an hour of your time. If I've got it wrong, tell me. I'd genuinely like to know.

The map

What's on this page

Ten short sections, about half an hour in all. Each one opens with a poster and a line from somebody who got there first. Most end with a yellow ticket: a small experiment you can try this week. The little loop that follows you down the page shows which part of the loop you're reading about, and its Contents link brings you back here.

The deeper bits are folded away under yellow + buttons. Tap one to open it.

z z Z BEFORE YOU WERE UP
01

This morning, before you were up

…before you finish eating breakfast in the morning, you've depended on more than half of the world.
1967Martin Luther King Jr, A Christmas Sermon on Peace

He was doing the same trick with his breakfast, and he even remembered the baker.

Before you'd finished your first cup of anything this morning, a crowd of people had already looked after you. You didn't meet a single one of them. Let's find a few.

What did you use before nine o'clock today?

Fig. 1 Tap anything you used. Each chain is the lazy version: a handful of people per thing, when the real chain goes back further than anyone could draw.

The yogurt was safe because a dairy worker followed a protocol, a Trading Standards officer turned up at a factory nobody else visits, and someone in a building you'll never see signed off a temperature reading. None of them knew you. They looked after you anyway. I find that genuinely moving. (I once followed this chain back in the sixth hour of a silent retreat and had to go and sit in the car for a bit.)

That's what I mean by service. And the strange part, the part that has kept me writing for five years, is that we've organised the world so that it mostly can't see any of it. Our dashboards can't count it, and for thirty years our politics quietly assumed nobody really does it. So who's noticing? Who thanks the Trading Standards officer? Does anyone outside the office even know their name? Mostly, no. And yet here you are, held up by them.

You'll bump into a few people along the way.

Meet the cast

Five people you'll bump into on the way down the page
My dad, the bakerTwenty-five years of 4am starts, for people he'd never meet.
Dr HabershamMy old GP. Walked you down the corridor himself.
The Trading Standards officerTurns up at the factory. Nobody claps.
Success EduanSprinter and student midwife from Manchester. Won European 4x100m relay gold for Great Britain in Birmingham this August.
The cow on the hillsideFrom a story by the Zen teacher Thich Nhat Hanh. Her milk makes the yogurt that fuels a monk's morning talk, so in a way she gives the talk too. She'll never know.

Where I've written about this: Everything Depends on Everything · You Can't Do Your Own Research · Service over time

SERVICE OVER TIME fire · wheel · writing · electricity · my toast
02

Service over time

…a partnership not only between those who are living, but between those who are living, those who are dead, and those who are to be born.
1790Edmund Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France

Burke was writing about how a society holds together across generations. He's right that it runs both ways: back to the dead, and forward to people not yet born.

So far it's all been strangers who are alive at the same time as you. But the chain goes back much further than this morning, and most of the people in it are dead.

Fill up the car and you're pouring in millions of years of compressed, long-dead lives, all of that energy spent, in that moment, getting you to the post office. Make toast and you're using the work of everyone who worked out how to pull copper out of the ground, how to get from fire to electricity, and how to agree on a plug socket. Walk into a library and three thousand years of people thinking are bundled up into letters on a shelf, waiting for you. Democracy, rickety as it is, was imagined, built and maintained by people who never met you, so that you could doss about, occasionally vote and mostly sound off about whatever you like. Amazing.

I call this service over time, and I think it might be the most noble kind, because nobody intended it and nobody got paid. No one was thinking about my toast a thousand years ago, but here I am, with my toast. I'd thank them if I could.

It also cured me of worrying about legacy. People talk about their legacy as if it'll have their name on it. Mostly that's ego. Time forgets us all. (It will certainly forget me.) Collectively, though, we're massive. The service we pay forward without knowing it, to people we'll never meet, is the real legacy, and it's a pretty good one. The Buddhists call this paṭicca-samuppāda, dependent origination: a flower includes the whole world, and a person includes the whole of humanity.

And now something new has joined the chain. Everything in it so far, from the first cell to whoever laid the cable under the Atlantic, ran at some level on the logic of genes: survive, look after your own, and now and then look after strangers. AI owes its existence to all of them: mathematicians long dead, the engineers who built the transistor, miners pulling rare earths out of the ground, and millions of writers whose sentences it learned from (mostly without asking them). But it's the first thing on this planet that can act on its own without serving anybody's genes. Whatever it hands forward will follow a different logic, written partly by us. Amazing, and a bit unnerving. I'll come back to the machines near the end, once we've got the loop in hand.

Where I've written about this: Service over time · Everything Depends on Everything

SERVARE to watch over · to keep safe
03

What I mean by the word

No one is useless in this world who lightens the burden of it for any one else.
1865Charles Dickens, Our Mutual Friend

Bella Wilfer has just announced that she's useless. John Rokesmith isn't having it.

In Boston a few years ago I bailed on a business dinner and went to the public library instead (ex-librarian, can't help it). I asked where the books about service were. There wasn't a shelf. There were shelves for hospitality, theology, public administration and economics, each with its own idea of service that fell over the moment you carried it into the next room.

So I made my own, and kept it plain:

Helping someone or something move from one state into another, better state.

That's it. (I tried to make it shorter. I couldn't.) It holds the GP and the bin man and my dad pulling loaves out of the oven at four in the morning for people who were still asleep.

The word has two roots tangled together. The old one, ser-, means to watch over, to keep safe. Then Rome laid servus, the slave, on top of it, and the two meanings have travelled together ever since. When people wince at "service" it's the second one they're hearing. I mean the first, the lighthouse keeper, while keeping an eye on the second, because it has a habit of sneaking back in when nobody's looking.

I should also say early on that this is a secular argument. You don't need to believe in anything to follow it, beyond the people who made your breakfast. But the religions noticed all of this centuries before the economists did, partly because they spent a very long time running kitchens, hospitals and almshouses, and they described it beautifully. So you'll hear from a monk, a preacher and a Zen teacher along the way, as witnesses rather than authorities, and I'm glad of every one of them.

Where I've written about this: Where Does Service Come From? · Service is nonsense

BACK TO THE GIVER
04

Service is a loop

The course of a benefit is from hand to hand, back to the giver.
c. AD 60Seneca, On Benefits, translated by Aubrey Stewart

He was explaining why the three Graces dance in a ring. If a single link fails, he adds, the beauty of the whole chain is lost. Try cutting the return below and see.

Here's the picture I draw on every whiteboard I get near. Someone gives. Someone receives. Usually something sits in between carrying it across the distance: a shop, a surgery, a council, an app. I call that the conduit.

And then, my favourite bit, something comes back. The regular tells my dad the bread was good. Dr Habersham used to walk you down the corridor to his room himself, partly because he was kind and partly because he'd started the diagnosis by watching how you walked. He was getting something out of that corridor too.

That return is the half nobody counts, and it's what lets the giver come back tomorrow. Twenty-five years of 4am starts needs a very full tank. Here's the whole thing as one picture, the service loop. Have a play.

The service loop A giver on the left and a receiver on the right. Between them at the top sits the conduit, the shop, surgery, council or app that carries the service across the distance. The service goes out from the giver through the conduit and arrives at the receiver, where it gets counted. A red line runs back underneath from the receiver to the giver: something comes back, the half nobody counts, and on its way it fills a store of trust. WHAT THE DASHBOARD SEES THE SERVICE LOOP goes out arrives something comes back: the half nobody counts trust store what carries it across the distance Conduit shop · surgery · council · app Giver their tank whoever serves Receiver better off whoever is served
Trust store: 40%. Giver's tank: three-quarters full. Receiver: a little better off.
Fig. 2 The service loop. The giver serves. The conduit (a shop, a surgery, a council, an app) carries it across a distance the two of them couldn't cover alone. The receiver ends up better off. Then something comes back along the red line and tops up the giver's tank and the trust store. Run a few loops, then cut the return and keep going: the receiver still gains, the dashboard still looks fine, and the giver quietly runs dry.

What it takes to keep the loop turning

Time, duration and an open outcome, what each end needs, and a sixth-century monk

For the loop to work, conditions have to be met and sustained on both sides. And both sides, giver and receiver, need the same three things.

What service needsWhat a transaction offers
TimeUsually an unpredictable amount of itA bounded slot
DurationStaying in it long enough for something to accumulateOne instance
OutcomeLeft open. The server needs the latitude to improvise, and the served person needs to tolerate the improvisation falling shortAgreed in advance

Which is interesting, because a transaction is precisely the opposite on all three counts. So the conditions for service amount to a disruption of transactional form, which is a lot more than a wish list of nice things. It explains why the seven-minute appointment, the fifteen-minute care visit, the average call handling time and the SLA all feel like the same attack. Because they are the same attack.

Then each end needs something the other doesn't.

The giver needs

Backing
Being allowed to use your judgement is one thing. Having someone stand behind you when it goes wrong is another.
Competence
Because only one side of this has to know what they're doing.
Restoration
Because serving uses something up, and it has to be put back.

The receiver needs

To disclose
To say what they actually want, which is harder than you'd think.
To depend
To accept being dependent for a moment, which carries a status cost most of us would rather not pay.

(I think a lot of what gets called entitlement is just someone refusing that cost. Claim it as a right and you never have to be a supplicant!)

Restoration is the one we've most thoroughly forgotten. St Benedict knew about it fifteen hundred years ago. In his Rule the monks took turns in the kitchen, and an hour before the meal that week's servers got an extra drink and some bread, so they could serve without grumbling or wearing themselves out. Somebody was minding the giver's tank in the sixth century. When did your employer last do that?

Trust is the store

And then there's trust. I had this diagram wrong for a while. I assumed trust was a condition, one of the things you need in place before service can happen. Then I realised it's the store, the little tank in the middle of Fig. 2. Trust is what a completed loop gives both sides, and it's what the next encounter draws on. That finally accounted for two things I could never explain: why a single bad experience can wipe out years of goodwill (you're draining the tank), and why a brand-new service relationship feels so precarious. Nothing is banked yet.

It's also why continuity is worth far more than it costs, and why almost nobody buys it. A store of trust only builds by completing the loop over and over with the same people, which takes years and turns up in nobody's quarterly numbers. So we keep rotating staff, and then wonder why the relationship never gets going.

Where I've written about this: Why You Should Care About Service · Dolly Parton, service hero

67% OF THE WORLD'S ECONOMY IS SERVICE World Bank and WTO, 2021
05

Three ways of looking at service

Service is the measure of greatness.
1900sWilliam Jennings Bryan, American orator and statesman

He said it decades before anyone invented GDP, which rather suits this section.

Serving, service, services. I used to think these were three topics. They're one thing at three sizes, and all the interesting stuff happens in the gaps.

And the big end is very big. Services now make up about two-thirds of the whole world's economy, up from just over half in 1970, and around four-fifths of Britain's. Even China, the workshop of the world, gets more than half its output from services. Every one of those trillions is built out of moments: someone cutting hair, answering a phone, changing a dressing, signing off a temperature reading. Billions of them, every single day! (I find that slightly dizzying. Most economics treats it as a productivity problem.)

one act

Serving

One person does something for another. My dad hands a loaf over the counter. It happens once and goes one way.

the loop

Service

The act closes into a loop and repeats. The regular comes back on Thursday. Something gets stored between them.

ten thousand loops

Services

script · metriccontract · form78%

The loop run for millions with nobody standing there: HMRC, a call centre, a school. In come the proxies.

Fig. 3 Serving, service, services. Each step up needs something to carry the conditions across the gap.

You can't have one baker per customer, so services are a genuine achievement. But every step up needs something to carry the conditions across the gap, and we used to have decent ones: the guild, the profession, the friendly society, vocation. Most have been swapped for proxies like the metric, the script and the compliance form. So the teacher's thank-you comes back as "78% at grade 4 and above", the share of her pupils who got a standard GCSE pass.

I'd go as far as saying that's most of the institutional problem: proxies scale beautifully, and the conditions they were standing in for hardly scale at all.

(I'm not standing outside this. I spent twenty years installing proxies and making dashboards go green, and I was trying to help, and on the measures we had, I did. That's rather the point.)

Where I've written about this: Why do big services damage those that serve? · Hostile Services · Bag-fold-and-smile

06

How the loop goes wrong

Once I had the loop, five years of scattered writing sorted itself into three piles. (Slightly embarrassing. I'd been standing somewhere different on the loop each time and hadn't noticed.) Then I saw that the piles weren't separate at all. They're one story, and it runs round the loop.

It starts with the red line, the return. A: our institutions count what goes out and can't see what comes back, so nobody protects it. B: follow that red line back to the giver and you find the consequence. With nothing coming back, giving stops replenishing anyone, and over fifty years we closed most of the places where ordinary people got to give at all. C: now go round to the other side. The people being served stop belonging to anything and become customers of everything, and a customer owes nothing, so nothing gets sent back. Which takes you straight back to A.

How the loop goes wrong: A on the red return line, B at the giver, C at the receiver, each leading to the next round the loop conduit B giver C receiver A the return
A · on the return · it starts here

The half nobody counts

Our institutions count what goes out and can't see what comes back, so nobody protects it.

B · at the giver · so

Starved of giving

With nothing coming back, the givers run dry, and the places where ordinary people could give close down.

C · at the receiver · and so

Customers of everything

People stop belonging and start shopping. A customer owes nothing, so nothing comes back, and we're at A again.

Fig. 4 How the loop goes wrong. Follow the arrows: A leads to B, B leads to C, and C feeds back into A. Tap a letter or a card to light up the pair.
OUT BACK THE HALF NOBODY COUNTS
06 · Part A of 3 · on the return · where it starts

The half nobody counts

Not everything that counts can be counted.
1963William Bruce Cameron, Informal Sociology

Usually pinned on Einstein. A sociologist wrote it, and almost nobody credits him, which feels about right.

Start with the red line. The modern way of running services can see half the loop. It counts what goes out and is more or less blind to what comes back. Most of what we experience as service failure is that blindness doing exactly what it was built to do.

I know this one from the inside. It took my family years, a tribunal and thousands of pounds to get my daughter an education plan. The council conceded without a hearing, which meant somebody had known all along. Then the plan arrived and the provision didn't. For months we couldn't get her a laptop. The sort Currys sells. Every email was courteous and nobody ever said no.

Have a guess

When a council in England refuses support for a child with special educational needs and the family appeals, how often does the council win at a tribunal hearing?

So the boiler's wired to a thermostat in the hallway. The hallway is always fine. The bedrooms are freezing. You can shout about the bedrooms for a decade and the boiler can't hear you, because it isn't connected to them. Nobody in that building is lying. That's the bit I still can't get past.

Have a guess

In a 4x100m relay, where are races usually won and lost?

Watching Great Britain win both 4x100m finals in Birmingham this summer, with Success Eduan on the third leg between midwifery shifts, I wanted to stand on the sofa. The baton never stopped. Four people, three blind handovers, and the thing they were carrying went faster than any of them could have run it alone. And almost every measurement system I built in twenty years measured legs.

The string quartet problem

An old puzzle in economics, and where it puts the sickness

There's an old puzzle in economics that explains a lot of this, and I love it. In 1966 two economists, William Baumol and William Bowen, pointed out that a Schubert string quartet still needs four players and the same length of time it did in 1826. Meanwhile nearly everything else got wildly more productive: a factory worker today turns out many times what her grandfather did in an hour. Wages rise across the whole economy, so the musicians have to be paid more too, and every year the quartet gets more expensive while staying exactly the same. Baumol called this a cost disease, and it's why teaching, nursing and care always seem to cost more without getting any better.

(Notice where the name puts the sickness. In the musicians.)

I think the illness is in the ruler. Productivity measures output per hour, and in a quartet, or a home visit, or a GP appointment, the hours of someone's attention are the output. Play the Schubert twice as fast and you get a worse Schubert. That's the edge of what the instrument can see, and past it the giver's attention is the good. It's also why you can predict where a service will break next: look for burnout behind green dashboards.

Where I've written about this: A machine for not doing things · Nobody wins a relay on their own leg · What economists get wrong about service

Next in 06: B · Starved of giving →
GIVING GROWS BACK
06 · Part B of 3 · at the giver · what A does

Starved of giving

Everybody can be great, because everybody can serve.
1968Martin Luther King Jr, The Drum Major Instinct

So that's the return, uncounted and unprotected. Follow the red line back to where it was supposed to arrive, the giver, and you find what happens next.

Around 2000 my dad asked what I wanted for Christmas and I asked for a sociology book called Bowling Alone. (It confirmed a long-held family suspicion that an alien had been left in the house.) I think I finally know why I wanted it.

People need to give at least as much as they need to be served, and over fifty years we've dismantled most of the places where ordinary people could.

Have a guess

Across European democracies, roughly what share of voters belonged to a political party in 1960, and by 2008?

Those organisations were never mostly about politics. Interwar Austria's social democrats ran a theatre club, a cycling club, a radio club and a rabbit breeders' association. You turned up on a Tuesday and did the lighting, and somebody needed you, specifically, every week.

Take away the places to give and the need doesn't vanish. It turns inside out. Out in public you get wanting without giving, which we call entitlement. And in private? A self that becomes a project that never finishes. I've had twenty years of therapy, I'm glad of it, and it kept locating my suffering inside me.

Which is where Alfred Adler comes in.

Freud's forgotten colleague

Alfred Adler, Berggasse 19, and the two questions a healthy life keeps asking

Everybody has heard of Freud. Far fewer people have heard of Adler, which is a shame, because he was right there in the room. He was a Viennese doctor, fourteen years younger than Freud, and from 1902 one of the handful of people who met on Wednesday evenings in Freud's flat at Berggasse 19 to invent psychoanalysis. By 1910 he was president of the Vienna Psychoanalytic Society. In 1911 he walked out.

The row was about where to look. Freud looked inwards, at drives and the unconscious. Adler looked outwards, at how a person stands in relation to everybody else. His word for it was Gemeinschaftsgefühl, which translators have wrestled with ever since: community feeling, social interest, fellowship, something close to comradeship. For Adler, how much of it you had was more or less the measure of your mental health. And he didn't leave it on the page. In the 1920s he set up child guidance clinics in Vienna's schools, working with teachers and parents in front of each other, out in the open, a very long way from the couch.

"What can I contribute to my fellows?"
"How can I fit in as part of the whole?"
1931Alfred Adler, What Life Should Mean to You. The two questions he thought a healthy life keeps asking.

He thought the people who cope best with life are the ones whose striving shows "a tendency to enrich everyone else". Freud won the twentieth century.

I think we picked the wrong one.

Thich Nhat Hanh describes a plant that grows back within a day of being cut, and comes back bigger the more you cut it. Giving's like that, he says, which contradicts everything I was ever paid to believe about capacity planning. But it only grows back if it's rooted. Most burnout comes from people made to give in conditions that were never theirs: no discretion, no continuity, and (my favourite) warmth specified in a tone-of-voice document three floors up.

(I need to pause for a moment. Women still do around two and a half times as much unpaid care as men. A call to give more must never become a polite way of taking more from the people already giving most.)

Where I've written about this: Wanting Without Giving · Service as Therapy? · The abundance of serving for free · Entitled to be served

Next in 06: C · Customers of everything →
FELLOWSHIP IS LIFE after William Morris, 1888
06 · Part C of 3 · at the receiver · what B does

Customers of everything

Fellowship is life, and lack of fellowship is death.
1888William Morris, A Dream of John Ball

Now go round to the other side of the loop. Starve the givers and close the places to give, and the people on the receiving end lose something too: the experience of being part of anything. Over forty years the citizen became a service user and the party member became a subscriber. Somewhere along the way I started thinking of myself as a purchaser of public services. We became customers of everything. A customer owes nothing and belongs nowhere, so when the service thins they withdraw their consent. Why wouldn't they?

Tax is where I caught myself. If tax is a purchase, I should get a refund for the school I don't use, and a two-week wait for the GP means I've been sold something faulty. The better version is an inheritance. I didn't build the courts or the roads or the drains. None of us did. We were handed them, and the bill is upkeep.

Being served asks something of the receiver too: saying what you actually want, sticking around long enough, accepting a partial answer (nobody has ever had a complete one, etc etc). Helping is a long series of compromises with an imperfect situation, which is why every good nurse, caseworker and bin man has been slightly, cheerfully soiled by the job. (In my experience the ones with clean hands have mostly kept them that way by not doing very much.)

The night of those relays I posted three hearts and three flags on Threads and woke up to 2,700 likes. If you want a test for who belongs to a country, use service. What do you hand on? Success Eduan will spend next year delivering other people's babies. Run the same test on the people loudly draping themselves in the flag.

And here's the cruel bit. Customers don't send anything back. They don't write the card. They don't tell the baker the bread was good. So the red line gets thinner still, and we're back at A.

Bleugh.

Where I've written about this: It's a crisis of service · The Words Starmer Used and Burnham Didn't · Why are public servants under attack so much?

That's the whole loop gone wrong. On to 07: what's underneath it →
07

Underneath all three

For thirty years the dominant story has been that we're individuals competing: rational maximisers surrounded by other rational maximisers. In that story, serving strangers looks like a rounding error, or a person who hasn't yet worked out what's in it for them. I was about ten when Margaret Thatcher said there was no such thing as society. I didn't buy it then. (Neither, as it happens, did the father of economics. Adam Smith opened his first book insisting that we're interested in each other's fortunes even when we get nothing from it "except the pleasure of seeing it".)

Drop that story into a school. The teacher came to teach. She gets a target, an inspection framework and a review that grades her against the woman next door. The honest ones learn to game it or leave. Sound familiar? A system built on the assumption that nobody really serves fills up with people being made to act as if they don't.

Humans all have wholesome and unwholesome tendencies, but unfortunately our modern institutions have a tendency to water the unwholesome ones, often in the name of misguided managerialism and capital. Here's someone who saw the whole thing a century and a half before me, and said it better:

The last lines of Middlemarch
…for the growing good of the world is partly dependent on unhistoric acts; and that things are not so ill with you and me as they might have been, is half owing to the number who lived faithfully a hidden life, and rest in unvisited tombs.
George Eliot, 1871-72

Unhistoric acts! The whole of this page is in those two words. So here's my version, in one sentence:

Everything you rely on is held up by people serving people they'll never meet, and we've built a world that can't see them.

Everything in section 06 follows from that blindness. It can't count the return, so the return goes unprotected. It stops keeping places to give, because why would anyone want them? And at the receiving end, the only relationship it can imagine is a customer's.

WHO GETS TO GIVE?
08

Arrival of the service machines

Only connect!
1910E. M. Forster, Howards End

I'm the COO of an AI company, so I can't write about this from a safe distance. I'm making some of the design decisions I've spent years warning about.

On the giving side, AI fixes things that wrecked human service at scale. It doesn't rotate off your case, doesn't forget what you said last time, doesn't have a handle time to hit, and doesn't flag on the ninth call of a shift. Some of the conditions industrial service destroyed are, for the first time, tentatively possible again.

But look at the loop. Automate the giving and the receiving may well get better, while the giving itself disappears. Every business case I've ever seen books the person doing the serving as a cost, so removing them looks like pure gain. If giving is one of the main ways people get to feel useful and connected, we're about to delete it at industrial scale and congratulate ourselves on the savings. Will anyone notice when the condolence note starts writing itself? Will they mind? On a busy day I'm not sure I would, which worries me.

I haven't made my mind up. I'm building inside that uncertainty. Everyone asks whether the machine will serve us as well as a person. My question is a different one. What happens to us when we don't get to serve each other any more? Who do we turn into?

Where I've written about this: The Dilemma · How we're training our replacements, on the sly · The employees I didn't hire

CLOSE A LOOP NOBODY IS AN ISLAND NOT EVEN THE COW
09

Before you go, close a loop

No man is an island, entire of itself; every man is a piece of the continent, a part of the main.
1624John Donne, Devotions upon Emergent Occasions

I don't want to end on a diagnosis, because the most exhilarating thing about service is that it's happening all the time, all round you, and almost nobody's looking. Think of the sheer audacity of it. Someone books a village hall, sets out two hundred chairs and some apple juice at a pound a glass, and trusts that people will come. Someone sets up a library that posts a book every month to children she'll never meet, and it keeps arriving after she's gone. That's Dolly.

So the last experiment is the whole argument in one small act. Think of someone who served you and never properly heard what difference it made: a teacher, a nurse, a neighbour, the colleague who covered for you, the person who walked you down a corridor. Here's a note. Fill in the gaps and send it however you like.

Experiment 8 of 8 · try this
Fig. 5 A return flow, ready to send. Nothing you type here leaves this page.

If you send one, I'd love to hear what happened. Partly nosiness, partly the point: you're completing a loop and I'm curious what comes back. Reply to any Society of Service post, or come and subscribe if you're new.

And one last complication, because it's what I'm stuck on and I'd rather show you than hide it. Thich Nhat Hanh tells of a novice monk pouring his breakfast yogurt (yes, again) and pointing at the cow on the hillside. She's eating grass so he can have yogurt so he can give a talk in an hour, so the cow is giving today's talk too. She'll never hear it. The loop never closes to her at all.

A lot of the service that's mattered most to me works like that. It walks forward, away from you, into people you'll never meet. My dad has no idea whose grim Tuesday in 1987 a loaf of his bread made slightly better. Maybe the return, for the cow and for my dad, is in the noticing. Which is a very Buddhist answer, and a very inconvenient one if you've drawn a diagram with an arrow labelled "return flow" pointing the other way.

I haven't worked that one out yet. Answers on a postcard (or a thank-you note).

Where I've written about this: Feeling dystopian? Do the dishes. · The Buddha, service hero · Dolly Parton, service hero

10

So what?

Charity begins at home, is the voice of the world.
1642Sir Thomas Browne, Religio Medici

Browne was half grumbling about it. I'm taking it at its word.

Eight experiments. If you've tried even one, you'll have noticed something. None of them needed a minister, a budget or a new operating model. They needed you, somebody in front of you, and about four minutes.

So here's my claim, as plainly as I can put it. We are all part of the fabric of service, every one of us, every day, mostly without noticing. You were part of it this morning before you were up, and you'll be part of it again before you go to bed.

For forty years we've been taught to look upwards and outwards for care: to the NHS, the council, the bank, the app, the helpline. And soon the robots!! We expect public and private services to look after us, and when they don't we're furious, often rightly. I've spent a good chunk of my life being furious at them. (See part A. See my daughter's laptop.) I'm not letting them off. They should do better, and a lot of this page is about how.

But the core of it is smaller and closer than any of that. It's how you treat the person right in front of you. The colleague on the late shift. The teenager who won't get out of bed. The bloke in the queue taking his terrible day out on the checkout. Your mum, on the phone, asking the same question for the third time. The child represented as a number on the spreadsheet.

That's where the loop starts. Every big service, the hospital, the council, the 67% of the economy, is thousands of those small moments wired together. If the small moments go sour, nothing upstream can rescue them. Get them right and you'd be amazed what else people will forgive.

Which is why I've come round to that old line. Charity begins at home. I used to hear it as something people said to get out of putting money in the tin. Now I think it might be the most practical sentence on this page, as long as home means the kitchen, the ward, the office, the bus, the school gate. Wherever you are, with whoever's in front of you.

With kindness, compassion and care. That is the key.

Go on, then.

Where these words and ideas come from

Every quote and figure on the page, and where I found it
Martin Luther King Jr, "A Christmas Sermon on Peace" (1967) and "The Drum Major Instinct" (1968)
Breakfast and the half of the world, and greatness through service.
Charles Dickens, Our Mutual Friend (1864-65)
"No one is useless in this world…"
Seneca, On Benefits (c. AD 60), translated by Aubrey Stewart (1887)
The three Graces, and the benefit that travels hand to hand back to the giver.
The Rule of St Benedict (c. 530), chapter 35
Kitchen servers, and the extra bread and drink before the meal.
William Jennings Bryan, speeches and addresses (early 1900s)
"Service is the measure of greatness." Found via my own collection, Great quotes, great guys, great gals.
William Bruce Cameron, Informal Sociology (1963)
The line usually credited to Einstein.
Alfred Adler, What Life Should Mean to You (1931)
Freud's lesser-known contemporary, on community feeling (Gemeinschaftsgefühl) and contributing to the whole.
William Morris, A Dream of John Ball (1888)
"Fellowship is life."
Adam Smith, The Theory of Moral Sentiments (1759)
The opening paragraph, before anyone had heard of the invisible hand.
Sir Thomas Browne, Religio Medici (1642)
"Charity begins at home, is the voice of the world."
George Eliot, Middlemarch (1871-72)
Unhistoric acts and unvisited tombs.
E. M. Forster, Howards End (1910) and John Donne, Devotions upon Emergent Occasions (1624)
Connection, and nobody being an island.
Thich Nhat Hanh, The Heart of the Buddha's Teaching
The plant that grows back, the cow, and interbeing.
World Bank and WTO, Trade in Services for Development (2023); ONS, Index of Services
Services at 67% of global GDP in 2021 (53% in 1970), and around 79% of UK GDP.
Edmund Burke, Reflections on the Revolution in France (1790)
Society as a partnership between the living, the dead and the unborn.
William Baumol and William Bowen, Performing Arts: The Economic Dilemma (1966)
The string quartet and the cost disease.
Robert Putnam, Bowling Alone (2000)
The Christmas present, and the emptying of civic life.
Anton Jäger, Hyperpolitics
The membership figures and the Austrian rabbit breeders.
Martin Gurri, The Revolt of the Public
What breaks at the receiving end.
Ichiro Kishimi and Fumitake Koga, The Courage to Be Disliked
Adler for the twenty-first century.

The posters are original illustrations made for this page, drawn in the spirit of the Polish and Czech poster schools of the 1970s.